Reference Source

Jinhua Sanctity Cosmetic Co., Ltd. · 53-06 · CHINA

For Jinhua Sanctity Cosmetic Co., Ltd., import alert is 53-06; country is CHINA; import alert name is "Detention Without Physical Examination Of Cosmetics That are Adulterated and/or Misbranded Due to Color Additive Violations"; product is LARITZY LIP GLOSS - RICH Color (Deep Red Color) | LARITZY LIP GLOSS - TRICK Color (Pink Color with Mica) | Strawberry LIP BALM (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) | Raspberry LIP BALM (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) | Pomegranate LIP SCRUB (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) | Sweet Citrus LIP SCRUB (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) | Sugar Mint LIP SCRUB (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) | Vanilla LIP BALM (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) | Cinnamon LIP BALM (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) | Honey LIP BALM (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) | Cherry LIP BALM (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) | Pomegranate LIP SCRUB (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) | Strawberry LIP BALM (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) | Cinnamon LIP BALM (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) | Sugar Mint LIP SCRUB (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) | Honey LIP BALM (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) | Sweet Citrus LIP SCRUB (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) | Cherry LIP BALM (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) | Vanilla LIP BALM (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) | Raspberry LIP BALM (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) 7 (TONEY RED; Sudan III) -non-permitted; 26105-Sudan IV - non-permitted | Strawberry LIP BALM (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) | Pomegranate LIP SCRUB (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs); product code is 53 G - - 05 Lipstick (Makeup Preparations, not for Eyes) | 53 G - - 05 Lipstick (Makeup Preparations, not for Eyes) | 53 G - - 05 Lipstick (Makeup Preparations, not for Eyes) | 53 G - - 05 Lipstick (Makeup Preparations, not for Eyes) | 53 G - - 05 Lipstick (Makeup Preparations, not for Eyes) | 53 G - - 05 Lipstick (Makeup Preparations, not for Eyes) | 53 G - - 05 Lipstick (Makeup Preparations, not for Eyes) | 53 G - - 05 Lipstick (Makeup Preparations, not for Eyes) | 53 G - - 05 Lipstick (Makeup Preparations, not for Eyes) | 53 G - - 05 Lipstick (Makeup Preparations, not for Eyes) | 53 G - - 05 Lipstick (Makeup Preparations, not for Eyes) | 53 L - - 06 Moisturizing (Skin Care Preparations) | 53 L - - 06 Moisturizing (Skin Care Preparations) | 53 L - - 06 Moisturizing (Skin Care Preparations) | 53 L - - 06 Moisturizing (Skin Care Preparations) | 53 L - - 06 Moisturizing (Skin Care Preparations) | 53 L - - 06 Moisturizing (Skin Care Preparations) | 53 L - - 06 Moisturizing (Skin Care Preparations) | 53 L - - 06 Moisturizing (Skin Care Preparations) | 53 L - - 06 Moisturizing (Skin Care Preparations) | 53 L - - 06 Moisturizing (Skin Care Preparations) | 53 L - - 06 Moisturizing (Skin Care Preparations); date published is 09/04/2019; address is Jingdong Economic Development Zone , No. 429 Dong Sheng Road , Jinhua, Zhejiang CHINA, verified against its source on 2026-09-30.

Firm
Jinhua Sanctity Cosmetic Co., Ltd. verified
Import alert
53-06
Import alert name
"Detention Without Physical Examination Of Cosmetics That are Adulterated and/or Misbranded Due to Color Additive Violations"
Country
CHINA verified
Address
Jingdong Economic Development Zone , No. 429 Dong Sheng Road , Jinhua, Zhejiang CHINA verified
Date published
09/04/2019 verified
Product code
53 G - - 05 Lipstick (Makeup Preparations, not for Eyes) | 53 G - - 05 Lipstick (Makeup Preparations, not for Eyes) | 53 G - - 05 Lipstick (Makeup Preparations, not for Eyes) | 53 G - - 05 Lipstick (Makeup Preparations, not for Eyes) | 53 G - - 05 Lipstick (Makeup Preparations, not for Eyes) | 53 G - - 05 Lipstick (Makeup Preparations, not for Eyes) | 53 G - - 05 Lipstick (Makeup Preparations, not for Eyes) | 53 G - - 05 Lipstick (Makeup Preparations, not for Eyes) | 53 G - - 05 Lipstick (Makeup Preparations, not for Eyes) | 53 G - - 05 Lipstick (Makeup Preparations, not for Eyes) | 53 G - - 05 Lipstick (Makeup Preparations, not for Eyes) | 53 L - - 06 Moisturizing (Skin Care Preparations) | 53 L - - 06 Moisturizing (Skin Care Preparations) | 53 L - - 06 Moisturizing (Skin Care Preparations) | 53 L - - 06 Moisturizing (Skin Care Preparations) | 53 L - - 06 Moisturizing (Skin Care Preparations) | 53 L - - 06 Moisturizing (Skin Care Preparations) | 53 L - - 06 Moisturizing (Skin Care Preparations) | 53 L - - 06 Moisturizing (Skin Care Preparations) | 53 L - - 06 Moisturizing (Skin Care Preparations) | 53 L - - 06 Moisturizing (Skin Care Preparations) | 53 L - - 06 Moisturizing (Skin Care Preparations) each item verified
Product
LARITZY LIP GLOSS - RICH Color (Deep Red Color) | LARITZY LIP GLOSS - TRICK Color (Pink Color with Mica) | Strawberry LIP BALM (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) | Raspberry LIP BALM (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) | Pomegranate LIP SCRUB (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) | Sweet Citrus LIP SCRUB (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) | Sugar Mint LIP SCRUB (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) | Vanilla LIP BALM (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) | Cinnamon LIP BALM (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) | Honey LIP BALM (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) | Cherry LIP BALM (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) | Pomegranate LIP SCRUB (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) | Strawberry LIP BALM (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) | Cinnamon LIP BALM (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) | Sugar Mint LIP SCRUB (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) | Honey LIP BALM (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) | Sweet Citrus LIP SCRUB (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) | Cherry LIP BALM (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) | Vanilla LIP BALM (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) | Raspberry LIP BALM (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) 7 (TONEY RED; Sudan III) -non-permitted; 26105-Sudan IV - non-permitted | Strawberry LIP BALM (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) | Pomegranate LIP SCRUB (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) each item verified
FDA notes
UNIDENTIFIED RED COLOR - undeclared, non-permitted; Two unidentified Orange colors - undeclared, non-permitted | UNIDENTIFIED RED COLOR; | Unidentified Orange color - undeclared, non-permitted | 26100 - D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED; Sudan III) - non-permitted 26105 - Sudan IV - non-permitted | 26105-Sudan IV; 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED); | 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED; Sudan III) -non-permitted; 26105-Sudan IV - non-permitted | 26105-Sudan IV; 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED); | 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED; Sudan III) -non-permitted; 26105-Sudan IV - non-permitted | 26105-Sudan IV; 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED); | 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED; Sudan III) -non-permitted; 26105-Sudan IV - non-permitted | 26105-Sudan IV; 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED); | 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED; Sudan III) -non-permitted; 26105-Sudan IV - non-permitted | 26105-Sudan IV; 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED); | 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED; Sudan III) -non-permitted; 26105-Sudan IV - non-permitted | 26105-Sudan IV; 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED); | 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED; Sudan III) -non-permitted; 26105-Sudan IV - non-permitted | 26105-Sudan IV; 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED); | 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED; Sudan III) -non-permitted; 26105-Sudan IV - non-permitted | 26105-Sudan IV; 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED); | 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED; Sudan III) -non-permitted 26105-Sudan IV - non-permitted | 26105-Sudan IV; 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED); | 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED; Sudan III) -non-permitted; 26105-Sudan IV - non-permitted | 26105-Sudan IV; | 26100 - D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED; Sudan III) - non-permitted; 26105 - Sudan IV - non-permitted | 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED); | 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED; Sudan III) -non-permitted; 26105-Sudan IV - non-permitted | 26105-Sudan IV; 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED); | 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED; Sudan III) -non-permitted; 26105-Sudan IV - non-permitted | 26105-Sudan IV; 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED); | 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED; Sudan III) -non-permitted; 26105-Sudan IV - non-permitted | 26105-Sudan IV; 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED); | 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED; Sudan III) -non-permitted; 26105-Sudan IV - non-permitted | 26105-Sudan IV; 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED); | 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED; Sudan III) -non-permitted; 26105-Sudan IV - non-permitted | 26105-Sudan IV; 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED); | 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED; Sudan III) -non-permitted; 26105-Sudan IV - non-permitted | 26105-Sudan IV; 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED); | 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED; Sudan III) -non-permitted; 26105-Sudan IV - non-permitted | 26105-Sudan IV; 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED); | 26100 - D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED; Sudan III) - non-permitted; 26105 - Sudan IV - non-permitted | 26105-Sudan IV; | 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED; Sudan III) -non-permitted; 26105-Sudan IV - non-permitted | 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED); each item verified
Sourceaccessdata.fda.gov
Verified
Review by
DatasetFDA import alert red lists: firms subject to detention without physical examination

What the source says

Jinhua Sanctity Cosmetic Co., Ltd. Date Published : 09/04/2019 Jingdong Economic Development Zone , No. 429 Dong Sheng Road , Jinhua, Zhejiang CHINA

— accessdata.fda.gov, retrieved 2026-09-15

Where each value comes from

The values above are stated away from the sentence quoted with the answer, so the passage that states them is shown here too.

Product code, Product and FDA notes

53 G - - 05 Lipstick (Makeup Preparations, not for Eyes) Date Published: 09/04/2019 Desc: LARITZY LIP GLOSS - RICH Color (Deep Red Color) Notes: UNIDENTIFIED RED COLOR - undeclared, non-permitted; Two unidentified Orange colors - undeclared, non-permitted Problems: UNIDENTIFIED RED COLOR; 53 G - - 05 Lipstick (Makeup Preparations, not for Eyes) Date Published: 09/04/2019 Desc: LARITZY LIP GLOSS - TRICK Color (Pink Color with Mica) Notes: Unidentified Orange color - undeclared, non-permitted 53 G - - 05 Lipstick (Makeup Preparations, not for Eyes) Date Published: 12/09/2024 Desc: Strawberry LIP BALM (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) Notes: 26100 - D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED; Sudan III) - non-permitted 26105 - Sudan IV - non-permitted Problems: 26105-Sudan IV; 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED); 53 G - - 05 Lipstick (Makeup Preparations, not for Eyes) Date Published: 12/09/2024 Desc: Raspberry LIP BALM (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) Notes: 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED; Sudan III) -non-permitted; 26105-Sudan IV - non-permitted Problems: 26105-Sudan IV; 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED); 53 G - - 05 Lipstick (Makeup Preparations, not for Eyes) Date Published: 12/09/2024 Desc: Pomegranate LIP SCRUB (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) Notes: 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED; Sudan III) -non-permitted; 26105-Sudan IV - non-permitted Problems: 26105-Sudan IV; 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED); 53 G - - 05 Lipstick (Makeup Preparations, not for Eyes) Date Published: 12/09/2024 Desc: Sweet Citrus LIP SCRUB (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) Notes: 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED; Sudan III) -non-permitted; 26105-Sudan IV - non-permitted Problems: 26105-Sudan IV; 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED); 53 G - - 05 Lipstick (Makeup Preparations, not for Eyes) Date Published: 12/09/2024 Desc: Sugar Mint LIP SCRUB (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) Notes: 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED; Sudan III) -non-permitted; 26105-Sudan IV - non-permitted Problems: 26105-Sudan IV; 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED); 53 G - - 05 Lipstick (Makeup Preparations, not for Eyes) Date Published: 12/09/2024 Desc: Vanilla LIP BALM (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) Notes: 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED; Sudan III) -non-permitted; 26105-Sudan IV - non-permitted Problems: 26105-Sudan IV; 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED); 53 G - - 05 Lipstick (Makeup Preparations, not for Eyes) Date Published: 12/09/2024 Desc: Cinnamon LIP BALM (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) Notes: 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED; Sudan III) -non-permitted; 26105-Sudan IV - non-permitted Problems: 26105-Sudan IV; 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED); 53 G - - 05 Lipstick (Makeup Preparations, not for Eyes) Date Published: 12/09/2024 Desc: Honey LIP BALM (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) Notes: 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED; Sudan III) -non-permitted; 26105-Sudan IV - non-permitted Problems: 26105-Sudan IV; 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED); 53 G - - 05 Lipstick (Makeup Preparations, not for Eyes) Date Published: 12/09/2024 Desc: Cherry LIP BALM (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) Notes: 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED; Sudan III) -non-permitted 26105-Sudan IV - non-permitted Problems: 26105-Sudan IV; 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED); 53 L - - 06 Moisturizing (Skin Care Preparations) Date Published: 12/09/2024 Desc: Pomegranate LIP SCRUB (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) Notes: 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED; Sudan III) -non-permitted; 26105-Sudan IV - non-permitted Problems: 26105-Sudan IV; 53 L - - 06 Moisturizing (Skin Care Preparations) Date Published: 12/09/2024 Desc: Strawberry LIP BALM (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) Notes: 26100 - D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED; Sudan III) - non-permitted; 26105 - Sudan IV - non-permitted Problems: 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED); 53 L - - 06 Moisturizing (Skin Care Preparations) Date Published: 12/09/2024 Desc: Cinnamon LIP BALM (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) Notes: 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED; Sudan III) -non-permitted; 26105-Sudan IV - non-permitted Problems: 26105-Sudan IV; 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED); 53 L - - 06 Moisturizing (Skin Care Preparations) Date Published: 12/09/2024 Desc: Sugar Mint LIP SCRUB (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) Notes: 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED; Sudan III) -non-permitted; 26105-Sudan IV - non-permitted Problems: 26105-Sudan IV; 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED); 53 L - - 06 Moisturizing (Skin Care Preparations) Date Published: 12/09/2024 Desc: Honey LIP BALM (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) Notes: 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED; Sudan III) -non-permitted; 26105-Sudan IV - non-permitted Problems: 26105-Sudan IV; 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED); 53 L - - 06 Moisturizing (Skin Care Preparations) Date Published: 12/09/2024 Desc: Sweet Citrus LIP SCRUB (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) Notes: 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED; Sudan III) -non-permitted; 26105-Sudan IV - non-permitted Problems: 26105-Sudan IV; 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED); 53 L - - 06 Moisturizing (Skin Care Preparations) Date Published: 12/09/2024 Desc: Cherry LIP BALM (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) Notes: 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED; Sudan III) -non-permitted; 26105-Sudan IV - non-permitted Problems: 26105-Sudan IV; 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED); 53 L - - 06 Moisturizing (Skin Care Preparations) Date Published: 12/09/2024 Desc: Vanilla LIP BALM (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) Notes: 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED; Sudan III) -non-permitted; 26105-Sudan IV - non-permitted Problems: 26105-Sudan IV; 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED); 53 L - - 06 Moisturizing (Skin Care Preparations) Date Published: 12/09/2024 Desc: Raspberry LIP BALM (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) 7 (TONEY RED; Sudan III) -non-permitted; 26105-Sudan IV - non-permitted Notes: 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED; Sudan III) -non-permitted; 26105-Sudan IV - non-permitted Problems: 26105-Sudan IV; 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED); 53 L - - 06 Moisturizing (Skin Care Preparations) Date Published: 12/09/2024 Desc: Strawberry LIP BALM (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) Notes: 26100 - D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED; Sudan III) - non-permitted; 26105 - Sudan IV - non-permitted Problems: 26105-Sudan IV; 53 L - - 06 Moisturizing (Skin Care Preparations) Date Published: 12/09/2024 Desc: Pomegranate LIP SCRUB (LIP COLLECTION; 6 Hydrating Lip Balms & 3 Exfoliating Lip Scrubs) Notes: 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED; Sudan III) -non-permitted; 26105-Sudan IV - non-permitted Problems: 26100-D&C RED #17 (TONEY RED);

— all from accessdata.fda.gov, retrieved 2026-09-15

Source

Last verified against source: . Due for re-check by . This page as Markdown · OKF bundle · full dataset as JSON.

This one changes, and we watch it.FDA import alert red lists: firms subject to detention without physical examination is re-read on a schedule and every change is dated. Subscribe: Atom feed · JSON · what has changed so far.